And the same holds true for teetotalers: Those
who have non-drinking friends and relatives are more likely not to
consume alcohol themselves, a new study found.
“People are organized by their drinking behavior
more than would be predicted by chance alone,” said study lead author
Dr. J. Niels Rosenquist, a research fellow in the departments of
psychiatry and health-care policy at Massachusetts General Hospital and Harvard Medical School. “There appears to be clustering.”
The effect, which may be just as great as family
history and genetics, suggests that new interventions for alcohol abuse
may be in order.
“In addition to working with individuals who are
drinking more than is good for them, we need to come up with new ways
to address this on more of a public health level, looking at groups of
people and some of the settings in which they congregate and reinforce
each other’s drinking habits,” said Dr. Ralph Manchester, director of
the University Health Service at the University of Rochester in New York.
The study authors gathered data on more than
12,000 people who were participating in the long-running Framingham
Heart Study. People were asked about their alcohol consumption and
their social networks several times over a span of 30 years, from 1971
People whose friends or relatives drank heavily
were 50% more likely to also drink heavily compared to people who
weren’t connected with heavy drinkers. And they were 36% more likely to
consume a lot of alcohol if a friend of a friend was a heavy drinker,
the study found.
There was even a measurable effect if a friend
of a friend of a friend drank a lot — in other words, three degrees of
The researchers also found in general that being
surrounded by heavy drinkers increased the reported alcohol consumption
by about 70%, while being surrounded by abstainers decreased reported
alcohol consumption by half.
While drinking habits of friends and relatives
did influence individuals, how nearby neighbors and co-workers
conducted themselves did not.
The study findings are published in the April 6 issue of Annals of Internal Medicine.
Previous studies have found similar ripple
effects for weight gain, smoking, happiness and depression, but, unlike
alcohol, these went only one way. For example, if an individual was
around people who gain weight, that individual was more likely to pack
on pounds as well.
“There seems to be sort of a social
transmission, and this fits into that broader pattern,” said Dr. Marc
Galanter, director of the division of alcoholism and drug abuse at
New York University School of Medicine.
And the social-transmission factor seems to be stronger among females, though it’s not clear why.
“The gender of your friend is significant,
meaning that if you have two friends, male and female, and the male
started drinking heavily, that would be less likely to affect you than
if a female started drinking heavily,” said Rosenquist.
The question then is what could be the reason for that, Rosenquist said.
“This is pure speculation at this point, but it
may be something to do with social norms by gender,” he added. “For
example, women tend to drink less under certain social norms and, if
they start drinking heavily, it may be more noticeable among groups of
friends and colleagues and may have a bigger effect on their drinking
behavior than if a male started drinking heavily.”
Of course, some people have long suspected that heavy drinking could travel in social circles.
“We know from alcoholism treatment that you want
to stay away from people who have drinking problems if you have a
drinking problem,” Galanter said. “AA (Alcoholics Anonymous) says just
to sever your ties with those people to be sure that you stay